Mystic Hill Olde Barn Country Gift Shop

View from the road of Mystic Hill Olde Barn
A view of some of the products in Mystic Hill Olde Barn

Visit their historic, 160 year-old barn with 2 floors of unique country and rustic merchandise for sale, including moose, bear and wolf, along with local Amish wares.

They are the type of business where people come to converse, to enjoy the ambiance of the building, take pictures in their Amish buggy and, of course, shop for some treasures.

To round out your Amish experience, Mystic Hill Olde Barn Gift Shop is a must in your travels.

Hours of Operation:

April, May & Nov., Dec.

Thursday – Saturday 10 am – 5 pm. Closed Sun thru Wed.

June – October

Tuesday thru Saturday 10 am – 5 pm. Closed Sun & Mon

When They are Closed

On days and hours they are not open,
we ask that you please call as they live nearby.
(716) 912-0981


7840 Mosher Hollow Road
Cattaraugus, NY 14719
United States

Lat Long
42.33981, -78.95699 View on Google Maps
This tour was just an incredible learning experience. it was the highlight of our 30th wedding anniversary trip. I would not change a thing.
Bob & Mary from Lee, Massachusetts

Fred gave a lot of history behind the area and the customs and traditions of the Amish.  He picked out shops that he thought we would like ...

Donna from Dunkirk, NY with visitors from India
Liked the variety of places that we visited. We all had a good time. The baked goods were excellent and reasonable.
Linda from Hamburg, NY
We liked having a tour guide with us to explain and give details. Visiting with Amish craftsman, getting to hear their processes and procedures.
Marcia from Medford, Oregon
Pat customized the tour to the places we were interested in seeing. We visited Amish shops for candy, quilts, baskets, toys, and a few more.
Lisa from Batavia, NY

Photos, Videos & More