The Mustard Seed Restaurant

Mustard Seed Dining Room

The Mustard Seed Restaurant, operating out of a renovated 1920s house in the Heart of Amish Country, uses whole foods and locally grown produce and products whenever available.

Enjoy fresh salads, sandwiches, pastas, grilled fish, and more. There are options for all types of eaters, including organic, locally grown, vegan and vegetarian.

They make several types of bread from organic flours. Desserts are also housemade, using only the best ingredients available. The Mustard Seed is proud to serve grass-fed, hormone-free beef from well-treated happy cows!

Hours (Until November 11, 2017)

Thursday - Saturday 11:00 AM - 8:00 PM

Will re-open for 2018 season on March 1, 2018


Catering Menu: delivery available everyday with 24 hours notice.

Will book for in-house private parties Sunday through Wednesday, minimum 25 confirmed people.






315 Pine Street
South Dayton, NY 14138
United States

Lat Long
42.362163, -79.052431 View on Google Maps
Liked the variety of places that we visited. We all had a good time. The baked goods were excellent and reasonable.
Linda from Hamburg, NY

Fred gave a lot of history behind the area and the customs and traditions of the Amish.  He picked out shops that he thought we would like ...

Donna from Dunkirk, NY with visitors from India
This tour was just an incredible learning experience. it was the highlight of our 30th wedding anniversary trip. I would not change a thing.
Bob & Mary from Lee, Massachusetts
We liked having a tour guide with us to explain and give details. Visiting with Amish craftsman, getting to hear their processes and procedures.
Marcia from Medford, Oregon
Pat customized the tour to the places we were interested in seeing. We visited Amish shops for candy, quilts, baskets, toys, and a few more.
Lisa from Batavia, NY

Photos, Videos & More